Top Anglers vs Pisces Sportfishing in Cabo San Lucas

Top Anglers and Pisces are two of the most established fishing charter companies in Cabo San Lucas. Pisces has been on the water since 1980. Top Anglers since 2004. Both operate out of the marina, both put anglers on marlin, tuna, and dorado year-round, and both have tournament credentials.

But they are very different operations. Pisces runs 34 boats with contracted captains and a corporate booking system. Top Anglers runs 13 boats owned and operated by the Vargas family with direct booking and no middlemen.

This page breaks down the differences so you can decide which one fits your trip.

Quick Comparison

Company Background

Top Anglers

Top Anglers was founded in 2004 by Captain Victor Vargas with a single boat at Marina Principal. Over 22 years, the Vargas family grew the operation to 13 vessels while keeping every boat owner-operated. Victor still captains trips. His son Victor Jr. runs daily operations as COO. The family handles every booking directly.

When you call Top Anglers, you are talking to the people who will be on the water with you. There is no call center, no booking platform, and no commissioned sales team between you and the captain.

Pisces Sportfishing

Pisces was founded in 1980 and is one of the longest-running charter operations in Cabo San Lucas. Over 45 years, they have built the largest fleet in the marina with 34 boats ranging from 28-foot standard cruisers to a 116-foot Azimut Bennetti superyacht.

Pisces operates at a scale that no other Cabo charter matches. Their captains fish 300+ days per year, and some crew members have spent their entire careers with the company. They publish weekly fishing reports on their blog that are widely read by anglers planning Cabo trips.

Pisces earned the IGFA Lifetime Achievement Award for Conservation and was the first fleet in Mexico to switch exclusively to circle hooks for live bait fishing. Their tagging program, run in partnership with Grayfishtag Research, lets anglers name and track released fish online.

Fleet Comparison

Top Anglers: 13 boats, 23' - 45'

Top Anglers' fleet is built to cover every type of fishing trip in Cabo, from budget-friendly inshore pangas to tournament-class sportfishers.

Inshore and light tackle (1-3 anglers)

• 23' Panga -- $450 half-day / $570 full-day
• 26' Shamrock -- $650 half-day / $750 full-day

Offshore (4-6 anglers)

• 30' California -- $750 half-day / $850 full-day
• 31' Bertram -- $800 half-day / $900 full-day
• 33' Bertram -- $900 half-day / $1,000 full-day
• 32' Blackfin -- $1,100 half-day / $1,250 full-day

Premium offshore (6-8 anglers)

• 35' Bertram -- $1,100 half-day / $1,200 full-day
• 38' Bertram -- $1,200 half-day / $1,400 full-day

Tournament class (8-12 anglers)

• 35' CABO Flybridge -- $1,700 half-day / $2,100 full-day
• 36' Black Watch -- $1,700 half-day / $2,150 full-day
• 40' Florentino -- $1,300 half-day / $1,500 full-day
• 44' Viking -- $1,700 half-day / $2,300 full-day
• 45' CABO Express -- $1,700 half-day / $2,300 full-day

Every price includes captain, crew, fishing licenses, tackle, live bait (when available), ice, water, dock fees, and taxes. No additional charges.

Pisces Sportfishing: 34 boats, 28' - 116'

Pisces organizes their fleet into four tiers. Specific per-boat pricing is not listed on their website and must be obtained through their booking system or by phone.

What to know about Pisces pricing: The starting prices listed ($445, $1,100, $3,500, $1,200) are category minimums shown on their main website. Individual boat rates require contacting Pisces directly. Their booking page does not display prices inline. The "$1,200" luxury tier minimum likely reflects a shorter trip or smaller luxury vessel, as the 116' Capella would command significantly more.

What Is Included

This is where the two operations differ most. At Top Anglers, the published price is the final price. At Pisces, inclusions are not explicitly listed on a per-boat basis.

Reviews and Reputation

Top Anglers

• Google: 4.8 stars / 150+ reviews
• Facebook: 100% recommendation rate
• Nautical Pathfinder: Trusted Charter designation
• Review highlights: personal attention from the Vargas family, transparent pricing, captains who go above and beyond, family-friendly atmosphere

Pisces

• TripAdvisor: Travelers' Choice Award (2013-2023, 2025), mixed reviews across hundreds of entries
• Yelp: ~4.0 stars / 46 reviews
• Forum reputation: Generally respected as a reliable large-scale operation
• Review highlights: consistent catches with experienced captains, weekly fishing reports valued by the community, some negative reviews citing crew attitudes and boat condition on older standard-tier vessels

What the reviews tell you

Pisces has volume. With 34 boats running almost daily for 45 years, they have generated an enormous review footprint. The experience is consistent at the midsize and large tiers but more variable on the standard-tier boats, which is expected with a fleet of that size.

Top Anglers has a smaller review count but a higher average rating. With 13 boats and a family operating every trip, the experience is more consistent across the fleet. You are more likely to interact directly with an owner during your trip.

Tournament Credentials

Both Top Anglers and Pisces compete at the highest levels of international sportfishing, but their tournament profiles are different.

Top Anglers

• 2025 Bisbee's Black and Blue winner -- the richest fishing tournament in the world
• CIPS-M Big Game World Championship -- Captain Victor Vargas captained Team Mexico
• 2025 Pan-American Billfish Championship -- crew member earned bronze medal
• Nautical Pathfinder Trusted Charter designation

Pisces

• IGFA Lifetime Achievement Award for Conservation -- one of the most prestigious honors in sportfishing
• Billfish Foundation recognition -- Top Overall Marlin Release Captain Worldwide
• Grayfishtag Research -- Top Tagging Fleet in the Pacific Coast of Mexico
• Bisbee's East Cape Tournament -- first place (42' Hot Rod)
• 45+ years of tournament participation across multiple events

Top Anglers' tournament profile is concentrated in recent, high-profile wins. Pisces' profile spans decades and leans heavily toward conservation recognition, which reflects their institutional commitment to catch-and-release practices.

Booking Experience

Top Anglers

You book by calling, texting, emailing, or messaging the Vargas family directly.

• Phone: +52 624 122 1643
• WhatsApp: +52 624 358 7768 (Victor Jr.)
• iMessage: +1 619 600 9061 (Andy)
• Email: topanglers@gmail.com

When you book, you choose the specific boat. You know the captain. You communicate directly with the family before, during, and after your trip. There is no booking platform, no middleman, and no commission.

Pisces

Pisces uses an online booking system at booking.piscessportfishing.com. You can also book by phone.

• USA: 1-619-819-7983
• Toll Free USA: 1-877-286-7938
• Mexico: +52 624-143-1288
• WhatsApp: +52 624 220 6367
• Email: bookings@piscesgroupcabo.com

The booking system shows available boats by category but does not display per-boat pricing inline. You may need to submit a request or call to get a specific quote. With 34 boats, Pisces has more availability on short notice, which is an advantage for last-minute trips.

Who Should Book Top Anglers

• Families who want personal attention from the owner on the water
• Budget-conscious anglers who need a quality trip starting at $450 with everything included
• Anglers who want to know exactly which boat and captain they get before they pay
• Repeat visitors who value building a relationship with their charter company
• Anyone who wants zero hidden fees -- the published price is the final price
• Groups of 1-12 anglers across any fishing style (inshore pangas to offshore tournament boats)

Who Should Book Pisces

• First-timers who want the security of booking with the longest-established name in Cabo
• Large groups needing a mega yacht (60'-116') for luxury fishing or cruising
• Conservation-focused anglers who want to participate in fish tagging research
• Last-minute bookers who need availability on short notice (34-boat fleet = more open dates)
• Corporate groups who need luxury vessels with Seakeeper stabilizers for comfort
• Anglers planning longer trips who want to choose from 34 different vessel configurations

Our Verdict

Pisces and Top Anglers are both legitimate, established charter companies. You will catch fish with either one. The question is what kind of experience you want around the fishing.

Choose Top Anglers if you want a personal, family-run experience with transparent all-inclusive pricing, a guaranteed boat and captain at booking, and direct communication with the people who own and operate the fleet. Top Anglers covers the full range from $450 pangas to $2,300 tournament boats, and every price includes everything.

Choose Pisces if you want the widest possible fleet selection, access to mega yachts and luxury vessels over 60 feet, a conservation-first approach with fish tagging research, or you are booking last-minute and need maximum availability. Pisces' 45-year track record and IGFA recognition speak for themselves.

If you are deciding between the two for a standard offshore fishing trip in the 31'-45' range, Top Anglers offers more pricing transparency (every inclusion listed, no surprises) and a higher review rating. If you need a vessel over 45 feet or a luxury yacht experience, Pisces is your pick -- Top Anglers' fleet tops out at 45 feet.

Related Comparisons